Orange County & Los Angeles
Extortion Defense Attorney
Free, confidential phone consultations 24/7/365. Payment plans available.
The Short Answer
Extortion under Penal Code 518, often called blackmail, is obtaining property or forcing an official act through a wrongful threat: violence, accusation, or exposing a secret. It is a felony carrying two to four years. But the line between extortion and lawful hard bargaining, a legitimate demand, or a threat to sue is narrower than prosecutors suggest. Because the case turns on whether the threat was wrongful and whether the property was actually obtained through it, extortion charges are more defensible than their felony label implies.
Extortion accusations arise in messy situations: a business dispute where someone threatened to go public, a demand for money to keep quiet about an affair, a heated threat during a breakup or a debt disagreement. The law targets wrongful threats used to obtain property or coerce action, but it does not criminalize every hard demand or warning, and that distinction is where these cases are fought.
Farris Law Firm defends extortion and blackmail cases across Orange County and Los Angeles, examining closely whether the alleged threat was actually wrongful and whether the elements of the crime are truly present.
How Extortion Is Charged
Extortion (PC 518/520)
Using a wrongful threat to obtain property or money, or to compel an official act. A felony.
Threatening letters (PC 523)
Sending a written extortionate threat, chargeable even if no money changes hands.
Attempted extortion (PC 524)
Attempting the threat, a lesser but still serious charge when the demand was not completed.
The threat and the obtaining
Prosecutors must prove both a wrongful threat and that property or an act was obtained through it, or attempted.
Penalties for Extortion
A felony, with additional exposure when threats involve violence or target vulnerable victims.
| Charge | Level | Exposure |
|---|---|---|
| Extortion (PC 520) | Felony | 2, 3, or 4 years state prison and fines |
| Threatening letters (PC 523) | Felony | Comparable felony exposure even without payment |
| Attempted extortion (PC 524) | Wobbler | Reduced, but still serious, exposure |
| Aggravating factors | Enhancements | Threats of violence or vulnerable victims raise exposure |
Defenses That Work in Extortion Cases
The wrongful-threat and obtaining elements give a prepared defense real room:
- The threat was not wrongful: warning that you will sue or report a genuine matter can be lawful
- A legitimate claim: demanding money you are actually owed is not extortion
- No consent obtained through fear: the property was not actually gained through the threat
- Free speech and lawful negotiation, not coercion
- False accusation, common in bitter business and personal disputes
- Insufficient proof connecting you to the threat or the demand
Frequently Asked Questions
I threatened to sue unless they paid me what I was owed. Is that extortion?
Generally no. Threatening litigation to recover a genuine debt or claim is lawful hard bargaining, not extortion. The crime requires a wrongful threat used to obtain property you are not entitled to. The line matters, and where your demand rested on a legitimate claim, that is a strong defense.
What is the difference between extortion and robbery?
Both involve obtaining property through fear, but robbery takes it directly from a person by immediate force or fear, while extortion uses a threat (often of future harm or exposure) to make the victim consent to hand it over. They are charged differently and defended differently. See our robbery page for the contrast.
Can I be charged if I never actually got any money?
Yes: attempted extortion (PC 524) and sending a threatening letter (PC 523) are chargeable even when no property changes hands. That said, the absence of any completed transaction is meaningful evidence and often reduces exposure. Early defense can keep an attempt from being overcharged.
This came out of a business dispute. Does that help?
It often does. Many extortion prosecutions are really contract or business disputes where one side made an aggressive demand. Showing the context, the legitimate underlying claim, and the lack of a wrongful threat is exactly how these cases get reduced or dismissed.
Charged or under investigation? Talk to a defense attorney tonight.
Free, confidential phone consultation any hour, any day. Payment plans available.